The NOAA Ozone Depleting Gas Index

NOAA Earth System Research Laboratory, R/GMD, 325 Broadway, Boulder, CO 80305-3328
David.J.Hofmann@noaa.gov, Stephen.A.Montzka@noaa.gov

 

The Clean Air Act, as amended in 1990, includes the following section:

SEC. 603. MONITORING AND REPORTING REQUIREMENTS

(d) Monitoring and Reporting to Congress
(2) The Administrators of  the National Aeronautics and Space Administration and the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration shall monitor, and not less often than every 3 years following enactment of the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990, submit a report to Congress on the current average tropospheric concentration of chlorine and bromine and on the level  of stratospheric ozone depletion.  Such reports shall include updated projections of-
  (A)  peak chlorine loading;
  (B)  the  rate  at  which  the  atmospheric  abundance  of chlorine is projected to decrease after the year 2000; and
  (C)  the  date  by  which  the  atmospheric  abundance  of chlorine is projected  to return to a level of two parts per billion

In order to provide the information necessary to satisfy this congressional mandate, both NASA and NOAA have instituted global monitoring programs to keep track of ozone-depleting gases as well as ozone itself.  While the information that has been collected for the past 25 years has been used extensively in international assessments of the science of ozone layer depletion, the language of scientists often eludes the average citizen who has a considerable interest in the health of the Earth’s protective ultraviolet radiation shield.  Are the ozone-destroying chemicals declining in the atmosphere? When do we expect the ozone layer above Antarctica to fully recover?  Will the recovery be different for the ozone layer above mid-latitudes?  In order to make the answers to these questions easier to understand, NOAA has developed an index, the Ozone Depleting Gas Index (ODGI).  This index is derived from atmospheric measurements of chemicals that contain chlorine and bromine at sites across the globe (Figure 1).  It is defined here as being 100 at the time that NOAA’s observations indicated a maximum in ozone-depleting halogen gases, and zero for the level we anticipate will correspond to recovery of the ozone layer. 

Two different indices are calculated, one that is relevant for the ozone hole over Antarctica (the ODGI-A), and one that is relevant for the ozone layer at mid-latitudes (the ODGI-ML).  While both indices are derived from NOAA measurements of halocarbon abundances at Earth’s surface, separate indices for these different stratospheric regions are necessary to account for the unique nature of the Antarctic stratosphere compared to the stratosphere at mid-latitudes.

Locations across Earth's surface where regular measurements are taken Figure 1.  Locations across Earth’s surface where regular measurements of the atmospheric abundance of ozone-depleting gases are conducted by NOAA/ESRL.  The chemicals measured are listed in the Tables.

 

The Antarctic Ozone Depleting Gas Index (ODGI-A)

The Antarctic ODGI is estimated directly from observations of all long-lived, chlorine and bromine containing gases.  These observations provide a measure of the total number of chlorine and bromine atoms in the atmosphere that are likely to reach the stratosphere and contribute to ozone depletion in springtime above Antarctica.  Because air reaching the Antarctic stratosphere has been isolated from the troposphere for a long period (~6 years), nearly all of the halocarbons reaching the Antarctic stratosphere during springtime have degraded to inorganic forms that are potential ozone-depleting agents.  When the enhanced efficiency of bromine to destroy ozone compared to chlorine is also considered, this total halogen amount is called the Equivalent Chlorine burden of the atmosphere (or ECl).

Figure 2 shows ECl vs time from NOAA’s surface-based measurements and compares it with a future projection provided by the WMO/UNEP Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion baseline scenario (blue points and thick green line).  A lag time of 6 years is added to the baseline scenario to account for the approximate 6 years it takes for gases at Earth’s surface to reach the Antarctic stratosphere (thick blue line).  The range of ECl values relevant for the conditions in the Antarctic stratosphere over which the NOAA Antarctic Ozone Depleting Gas Index (ODGI-A) is defined is indicated in Figure 2.

The Equivalent Chlorine as a function of time Figure 2.  The Equivalent Chlorine, including both chlorine and bromine compounds, as a function of time showing NOAA measurements and a projection for the future provided by a WMO/UNEP scenario, which assumes that regulations of the Montreal Protocol will be followed.  The Ozone Depleting Gas Index relevant for the Antarctic Stratosphere (red scale on the right) had a value of 86.2 for the year 2006.
Click on image to view full size figure.

ODGI-A is defined here as being 100 at the time that NOAA’s surface-based observations indicated a maximum in ECl (1994).  The zero point of the scale is defined as the ECl level that existed when the Antarctic ozone hole first became easily detectable (about 2170 ppt ECl in about 1980), which is the ECl level when full recovery of the ozone hole is expected.  On this scale, the current value of ODGI-A is about 86, i.e., we have progressed about 14% of the way along the path toward a stratospheric halogen level that should allow an ozone-hole-free Antarctic stratosphere.  The latter has been projected to occur sometime in the around 2080 range as indicated by the recent WMO/UNEP Scientific Assessments of Ozone Depletion scenarios.  Though the recovery of the ozone layer depends critically on continued declines in halocarbon abundances in the future, the exact date for full recovery also depends upon future changes in other factors that influence ozone and that influence the efficiency of bromine and chlorine to destroy ozone, for example, climate change.

The contribution to Equivalent Chlorine by long-lived gases
Figure 3. The contribution to Equivalent Chlorine by all long-lived chlorine- and bromine-containing gases.
Click on image to view full size figure.

In order to see which gases are causing the decline in ECl, Table 1 and Figure 3 delineates the contributions of individual gases to ECl.  Of the ozone depleting gases restricted by the Montreal Protocol, the NOAA results show that nearly all were decreasing in the atmosphere by 2006.  The notable exceptions include the halons and HCFCs, which are used as replacements for CFCs in many applications.  It is clear from this Figure that most of the decline in ECl has been due to the relatively rapid phase out and atmospheric decline of short-lived chemicals such as methyl chloroform (CH3CCl3) and methyl bromide.  The decline related to CFC-11 and CFC-12, the two major ECl components, has been relatively small.  Though emissions of these two CFCs have declined substantially over the past 15 years, their atmospheric decay has been slow because their lifetimes are very long (50-100 years).  Methyl bromide and methyl chloride (CH3Br, CH3Cl) are unique among ozone-depleting gases because they have substantial natural components.  Halons continue to increase slowly in the atmosphere because of large banks or reserves that are slowly being emitted to the atmosphere.  Though HCFC’s continue to increase and production is not scheduled for a complete phase-out until 2040, they currently contribute relatively little to the atmospheric burden of ECl.

 

Table 1: The contribution of different ozone depleting chemicals and groups of chemicals to the ozone-destroying potential of the atmosphere (or Equivalent Chlorine, in parts per trillion or ppt), and the Ozone-Depleting Gas Index relevant for Antarctica (ODGI-A).
Year CFC-12 CFC-11 CH3Cl CH3Br CCl4 CH3CCl3 Halons CFC-113 HCFCs WMO
Minor
ECl
SUM (ppt)
ODGI
Antarctic
1992 1007 813 550 542 424 405 302 241 106 87 4476 97.6
1993 1022 816 550 542 421 387 323 246 111 91 4508 99.0
1994 1035 816 550 542 419 355 348 251 121 95 4532 100.0
1995 1045 814 549 537 416 318 357 252 130 98 4515 99.3
1996 1051 811 543 548 413 277 370 252 140 99 4504 98.8
1997 1057 807 546 544 409 236 380 250 150 100 4480 97.8
1998 1061 801 561 561 408 198 391 248 159 100 4488 98.1
1999 1064 793 562 544 405 165 403 247 169 99 4451 96.6
2000 1068 788 550 524 401 137 411 246 178 98 4401 94.5
2001 1070 782 541 498 396 114 414 244 188 96 4345 92.1
2002 1072 777 541 489 392 95 419 243 197 94 4319 91.0
2003 1072 770 542 487 390 80 423 240 205 93 4301 90.2
2004 1071 764 540 475 385 66 430 238 211 91 4271 88.9
2005 1068 756 539 468 380 55 432 236 218 89 4242 87.7
2006 1065 748 536 456 374 46 433 235 227 87 4208 86.2

Notes:  ECl is derived from ground-based measurements of Ozone Depleting Substances, with consideration given to the total number of chlorine and bromine atoms in each ODS, and the higher efficiency for bromine relative to chlorine in destroying ozone (a factor of 60 is used).  The Antarctic ODGI is derived from the measured ECl burden in the lower atmosphere, but it is made relevant for the stratosphere based upon ECl inferred for the stratosphere when the ozone hole was first observed (1980) and a lag time required for air at the surface to reach the polar stratosphere of 6 years.  “Halons” represents the aggregate of H-1211 and H-1301; “HCFCs” represents the aggregate of HCFC-22, HCFC-141b, and HCFC-142b; “WMO minor” represents CFC-114, CFC-115, halon 2402 and halon 1201.

 

The Mid-latitude Ozone Depleting Gas Index (ODGI-ML)

ODGI-ML is also estimated directly from observations of all long-lived, chlorine and bromine containing gases.  The calculation, however, is different from ODGI-A primarily because, owing to the closer proximity to the main chlorine and bromine gas sources (which are located predominantly in mid-latitudes of the Northern Hemisphere), air in the mid-latitude stratosphere has a younger mean ‘stratospheric age’ compared to air above Antarctica.  As a result, halocarbons in the mid latitude stratosphere have had less time to become degraded by Sun’s high-energy rays.  By accounting for compound-dependent degradation rates in the stratosphere, a younger mean stratospheric air age, and the enhanced efficiency for bromine to destroy ozone compared to chlorine, we derive a quantity known as the Effective Equivalent Chlorine (EECl) to represent how the burden of ozone-depleting halogenated gases are changing in the mid-latitude stratosphere. 

The Effective Equivalent Chlorine as a function of time Figure 4.  The Effective Equivalent Chlorine, including both chlorine and bromine compounds, as a function of time showing NOAA measurements and a projection for the future provided by a WMO/UNEP scenario, which assumes that regulations of the Montreal Protocol will be followed.  The Ozone Depleting Gas Index relevant for the mid-latitude stratosphere (red scale on the right) had a value of 74.6 for the year 2006.
Click on image to view full size figure.

Figure 4 shows EECl vs time from NOAA’s surface-based measurements and compares it with a future projection provided by the WMO/UNEP Scientific Assessment of Ozone Depletion scenario (points and thick green line).  A lag time of 3 years is added to the surface-based observations to account for the approximate 3 years it takes for gases at Earth’s surface to reach the stratospheric ozone layer in mid-latitudes (thick blue line).

The range of EECl values relevant for the conditions in the mid-latitude stratosphere over which the NOAA Antarctic Ozone Depleting Gas Index (ODGI-ML) is defined is indicated in Figure 4.  Similar to ODGI-A, the ODGI-ML is defined as 100 at its peak, and zero at the level corresponding to when recovery might be expected in the mid-latitude stratosphere.  Based upon halocarbon abundances inferred for the mid-latitude stratosphere in 1980, we expect this recovery level to be approximately 1825 ppt EECl, or somewhat less than required for full recovery in Antarctica.  On this scale, the current value of the ODGI-ML is about 75, i.e., we have progressed about 25% of the way along the path toward a stratospheric halogen level that would allow a normal ozone layer.  The latter has been projected to occur in mid-latitudes sometime around the 2050 range (see Figure 4) in recent WMO/UNEP Scientific Assessments of Ozone Depletion scenarios.  Though the recovery of the ozone layer depends critically on continued declines in halocarbon abundances in the future, the exact date for full recovery also depends upon future changes in other factors that influence ozone and that influence the efficiency of bromine and chlorine to destroy ozone, such as climate change.

The contribution to Effective Equivalent Chlorine by all long-lived chlorine and bromine containing gases
Figure 5.  The contribution to Effective Equivalent Chlorine by all long-lived chlorine- and bromine-containing gases.
Click on image to view full size figure.

As in Figure 3, Figure 5 and Table 2 delineate the contributions of individual gases to EECl.  The same gases that drive the declines in ECl and the ODGI-A also cause the decrease in EECl and the ODGI-ML.  Some interesting differences can be noted, however.  For example, because of its relatively rapid degradation in the mid-latitude stratosphere, CFC-11 contributes more than CFC-12 to EECl and the ODGI-ML.  Furthermore, HCFCs are only partially degraded in the mid-latitude stratosphere and, as a result, account for an even smaller increase in the ODGI-ML than in the ODGI-A.  As was the case for the ODGI-A, most of the decline in EECl has been due to the relatively rapid phase out and atmospheric decline of short-lived chemicals such as methyl chloroform (CH3CCl3) and methyl bromide.  Also, the decline related to CFC-11 and CFC-12, the two major EECl components, has been relatively small.  Though emissions of these two CFCs have declined substantially over the past 15 years, their atmospheric decline has been slow because their lifetimes are very long (50-100 years).

 

Table 2: The contribution of different ozone depleting chemicals and groups of chemicals to the ozone-destroying potential of the atmosphere (or Effective Equivalent Chlorine, in parts per trillion or ppt), and the Ozone-Depleting Gas Index relevant for mid-latitudes (ODGI-ML).
Year CFC-12 CFC-11 CH3Cl CH3Br CCl4 CH3CCl3 Halons CFC-113 HCFCs WMO
Minor
EECl
SUM (ppt)
ODGI
Mid Latitude
1992 483 650 352 485 359 350 227 144 30 55 3137 98.5
1993 490 653 352 485 357 334 243 147 32 58 3151 99.6
1994 497 653 352 485 355 307 260 151 35 61 3156 100.0
1995 502 651 351 481 353 274 268 151 38 63 3134 98.3
1996 505 649 348 491 350 240 279 151 42 64 3118 97.2
1997 507 646 350 487 347 204 288 150 46 64 3091 95.1
1998 509 641 359 502 346 171 297 149 50 64 3088 94.9
1999 511 635 359 487 343 143 306 148 54 63 3050 92.0
2000 513 630 352 470 340 119 312 147 58 62 3003 88.5
2001 514 626 346 446 336 99 316 147 61 61 2951 84.5
2002 514 622 346 438 333 82 320 146 64 59 2924 82.5
2003 515 616 347 436 330 69 323 144 67 58 2905 81.1
2004 514 611 346 426 327 57 327 143 69 56 2875 78.8
2005 513 605 346 419 323 48 328 142 72 55 2849 76.8
2006 511 598 348 409 317 40 328 141 74 53 2820 74.6

Notes:  EECl is derived from ground-based measurements of Ozone Depleting Substances (ODS), with consideration given to the number of chlorine and bromine atoms in each ODS, the rate at which these ODS photolytically decompose in the mid-latitude stratosphere, and the higher efficiency for bromine relative to chlorine in destroying ozone (a factor of 60 is used).  The mid-latitude ODGI is derived from the measured EECl burden in the lower atmosphere, but it is made relevant for the stratosphere based upon EECl inferred for the stratosphere when the ozone hole was first observed (1980) and a lag time required for air at the surface to reach the polar stratosphere of 3 years.  “Halons” represents the aggregate of H-1211 and H-1301; “HCFCs” represents the aggregate of HCFC-22, HCFC-141b, and HCFC-142b; “WMO minor” represents CFC-114, CFC-115, halon 2402 and halon 1201.

 

 

Sustained declines in atmospheric chlorine and bromine in future years hinges upon continued adherence to the production and consumption restrictions outlined in the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer.  Recovery of the ozone layer is expected during this period as the ODGI approaches zero, though the timing of ozone layer recovery is difficult to determine exactly because other chemical and physical factors such as climate change also influence stratospheric ozone abundances and the efficiency for chlorine and bromine to destroy stratospheric ozone.

The ODGI-A and ODGI-ML represent important components of NOAA’s effort to guide the recovery of the ozone hole over Antarctica and the mid-latitude ozone layer.  These indices provide a means by which adherence to international protocols can be assessed and allow the public and policy makers to discern if policy measures are having their desired effect.  Because ozone depletion is still near its peak, continued monitoring of ozone and ozone depleting gases is critical for ensuring that the recovery proceeds as expected through the 21st century.